Fantasy Debate; Tight Ends

[mike]

Which Tight End do you like better for this coming season and which would you rather have in a keeper league.

Dallas Clark or Antonio Gates

[HybridTheory]

Clark. He's a WR and is healthier than Gates.

[norrisb]

Gates, he's the best TE and even when he's injured he still puts up 2800+ yds, I cant say the same about Mr. Glass Dallas Clark

[DDS]

Dallas Clark for me.

[hobbs]

Tough one there but I gotta go with Gates, Rivers will be around longer than Peyton imho and that weighs into the decision in a Dynasty league.

[mike]

I bring this up because I have Clark and was thinking about going after Gates because of age. Have not done any number searching or anything yet though.

[norrisb]

this is their 6 year spread:

2004-2009

Gates: 1,1,1,2,4,3

Clark: 11,14,16, 5, 3, 2


Gotta like Mr. Gates consistency that's for sure

[DDS]

this is their 6 year spread:

2004-2009

Gates: 1,1,1,2,4,3

Clark: 11,14,16, 5, 3, 2


Gotta like Mr. Gates consistency that's for sure

looks like Clark is constantly improving to me

[hobbs]

looks like Clark is constantly improving to me

Improving to stay closer but always behind Gates.

[DDS]

Improving to stay closer but always behind Gates.

not the past two seasons